View all press and media

November 17, 2026

New Medefy Claims Analysis Finds About Half of Employer Medical Spend Is Fixable

A read of more than 11 million claim lines across four self-funded health plans found 40% to 55% of medical spend on every plan was scheduled care that cost far less a few miles away, inside the same network.

The Fixable Half, a Medefy claims analysis, Fall 2026

The Fixable Half, a Medefy claims analysis, Fall 2026

TULSA, Okla., November 17, 2026. About half of what employers spend on medical care can be fixed, according to a new claims analysis from Medefy Health, a cost containment system that aligns benefits consultants, HR teams and members around the decisions that put a stop to runaway healthcare costs. The report, The Fixable Half, read more than 11 million claim lines from four self-funded employer health plans. On every plan, 40% to 55% of medical spend was fixable. That held on three unrelated plans that aren’t Medefy clients and on one of Medefy’s largest clients.

The fixable half is scheduled care, including imaging, labs, outpatient surgery, planned inpatient procedures and infusion. It is care booked weeks out, where the same service costs far less at another site in the same network. The rest is care no one can move, such as emergencies, trauma and catastrophic claims.

The findings land as employers set next year’s budgets. The report finds that Q4 medical spend ran about 20% higher than the rest of the year on all four plans, two years in a row. That jump is not inflation. About half comes from the plan paying a bigger share once members meet their deductibles. The other half is members choosing more care at higher-priced sites, and that half can be steered.

“Ask an employer what’s driving their health costs and you’ll hear one word. Cancer,” said Nathan Gilchrist, co-founder and Chief Product Officer of Medefy. “That answer is right, but almost none of that spend can move without stepping into a clinical decision. So we took everything you can’t touch off the table first and asked what was left. We read more than 11 million claim lines to find out. The answer held on every plan, three that have never been our clients and one of our largest. Every plan landed between 40% and 55%. That’s about half. It’s lower than the market tends to promise, and it’s real money a plan can move without asking anyone to make a worse clinical choice.”

Key findings

  • About half of medical spend is fixable. Each of four unrelated plans landed between 40% and 55%. The three non-client plans averaged 47%.
  • Q4 runs about 20% hotter, and it isn’t inflation. Half the jump is cost share shifting to the plan after deductibles are met. The other half is steerable.
  • Most scheduled care went to the highest-priced sites. 80% of imaging dollars, and more than half of lab, infusion and surgery dollars, went to the most expensive type of facility.
  • The same procedure cost 48% less a few miles away. That is the average gap across every matched procedure priced on all four plans. Both sites were already in network.
  • Fixing it compounds. On one plan Medefy has served for six years, claims-verified savings grew in every measured year.

“Every benefits consultant, HR leader and CFO we talk to is feeling the same cost pressure right now,” said Matt Scovil, co-founder and CEO of Medefy. “Renewals are landing and the number is painful. Employers don’t want to cut benefits if they can help it, and shifting cost to employees is maxed out. Benefits consultants are working overtime to bring relief. We purpose-built our AI to help them all. The consultant sees where the money is burning and gets suggested solutions that are proven needle-movers. Engagement goes out automatically for HR. Members are engaged to change behavior and spend less. The reduction is proven in the plan’s own claims. When the benefits consultant, HR and members pull together, the fixable half gets fixed.”

How the analysis was done

Medefy analyzed more than 11 million paid medical claim lines from four self-funded employer plans, measured against each plan’s own paid claims rather than market benchmarks or list prices. One plan is a Medefy client, read across six plan years. The other three are not clients and share no carrier, network, industry or region. Their figures are anonymized and rounded.

The Fixable Half is written for benefits consultants and the employers they serve. It includes a checklist to use before the next renewal and five questions to ask every vendor on a health plan.

Read the full report at medefy.com/resource/the-fixable-half.

About Medefy

Medefy Health is a cost containment system based in Tulsa, Oklahoma. Medefy helps employers, benefits consultants, public sector agencies, TPAs, and health plans find where healthcare costs are leaking and move members toward lower-cost, right care, all year long, not only at renewal. Savings are proven in each client’s own claims, not projected from a model. Medefy’s public sector portfolio includes state and municipal health plans across the country, and Medefy reaches more than a million members overall. Learn more at medefy.com.

Media contact

Genevieve Longtin, VP of Marketing
Contact us